Academic
Publications
Fuzzy regression methods - a comparative assessment

Fuzzy regression methods - a comparative assessment,10.1016/S0165-0114(99)00091-3,Fuzzy Sets and Systems,Yun-hsi O. Chang,Bilal M. Ayyub

Fuzzy regression methods - a comparative assessment   (Citations: 72)
BibTex | RIS | RefWorks Download
The fundamental differences between fuzzy regression and ordinary regression are identified in this paper. Fuzzy regression can be used to fit fuzzy data and crisp data into a regression model, whereas ordinary regression can only fit crisp data. Through a comprehensive literature review, three approaches of fuzzy regression are summarized. The first approach of fuzzy regression is based on minimizing fuzziness as an optimal criterion. The second approach uses least-squares of errors as a fitting criterion, and two methods are summarized in this paper. The third approach can be described as an interval regression analysis. For each fuzzy regression method, numerical examples and graphical presentations are used to evaluate their characteristic and differences with ordinary least-squares regression. Based on the comparative assessment, the fundamental differences between ordinary least-squares regression and conventional fuzzy regression are concluded – that is, ordinary least-squares regression modeling data with randomness type of uncertainty, and conventional fuzzy regression modeling data with fuzziness type of uncertainty. In order to integrate both randomness and fuzziness types of uncertainty into one regression model, the concept of hybrid fuzzy least-squares regression analysis is proposed in this paper, and the details of its method are derived in the accompanying paper.
Journal: Fuzzy Sets and Systems - FSS , vol. 119, no. 2, pp. 187-203, 2001
Cumulative Annual
View Publication
The following links allow you to view full publications. These links are maintained by other sources not affiliated with Microsoft Academic Search.
    • ...In order to integrate both random and fuzzy types of uncertainty into one regression model, a fuzzy least-squares regression was introduced by Chang (Chang 2001, Chang and Ayyub 2001) to model manufacturing processes which can address both the fuzziness and the randomness of a system in the development of a fuzzy least-squares regression model...

    Kit Yan Chanet al. Handling uncertainties in modelling manufacturing processes with hybri...

    • ...The deviation between the observed data and the estimated data encountered in classical regression is because of the measurement error or random variations of parameters [7]–[9]...
    • ...Such random variations can be represented as a normal distribution of some variance and zero mean, which makes statistical techniques effective in determining the functional relationship for such types of data [7]...
    • ...The FR model is referred to as a fuzzy or possibilistic model of classical regression, while classical regression is based on the principles of statistics [7]...
    • ...In the former approach, the aim is to minimize the overall fuzziness by minimizing the total spread of the fuzzy coefficients, while the estimated outputs and the observed ones are within a certain h-level of confidence [7], [20]...
    • ...The term h expresses the fitness between the estimated fuzzy outputs and the observed ones [7]...
    • ...On the other hand, in the LS-based model, a similarity measure between observed and estimated outputs is used as the measurement for the fitness of the model [7], [8]...

    M. Hadi Mashinchiet al. A Tabu–Harmony Search-Based Approach to Fuzzy Linear Regression

    • ...In order to integrate both random and fuzzy types of uncertainty into one regression model, a fuzzy least-squares regression was introduced by Chang (Chang 2001, Chang and Ayyub 2001) to model manufacturing processes which can address both the fuzziness and the randomness of a system in the development of a fuzzy least-squares regression model...

    Kit Yan Chanet al. Handling uncertainties in modelling manufacturing processes with hybri...

    • ...As pointed out by Wang and Tsaur [37, 38], the advantage of this approach is its simplicity in programming and computation, but it has been criticized to provide too wide ranges in estimation which could not give much help in application [38] and not to utilize the concept of leastsquares [15]...
    • ...Different aspects of this approach were investigated by Celmins [12, 13], Diamond [20], Savic and Pedrycz [33], and Chang and Ayyub [15] Celmins [12, 13] defines a compatibility measure between fuzzy data and a model, and uses this measure as a model-fitting criterion...
    • ...Chang and Ayyub [15] discussed reliability issues of FLSRA such as standard error and correlation coefficient...
    • ...8i ¼ 1; ��� ;M; aj 2 R;cj � 0; j ¼ 1;2; ��� ;N;xi0 ¼ 1; 0 � l � 1: Chang et al. [15] introduced a FLR model...
    • ...Chang and Ayyub [15] (Eq. 10) The input and output data are crisp but coefficients are triangle fuzzy numbers...

    A. Azadehet al. An integrated fuzzy regression–analysis of variance algorithm for impr...

    • ...Ayyub [11] in current literature, where the coefficients of input variables are assumed to be fuzzy numbers...

    O. Poleshchuket al. A nonlinear hybrid fuzzy least-squares regression model

Sort by: